SoundMan X2: Visually Stunning, Aurally Underwhelming
   Widely recognized for 
    high quality input devices such as gaming controllers, keyboards and mice, 
    Logitech enters the middle end sound arena with a visually appealing series 
    dubbed "SoundMan." The X2 model sports stunning good looks and the 
    wide mouth sub port is right out in the open--on top where all can see. This 
    gives rise to hauling it from place to place by slipping your hand inside 
    the port since the entire unit is round. The satellites are so tiny and unobtrusive 
    that many wouldn't even notice if the X2's were installed at their workstation. 
    If "hip to be round" is your motto (to slightly modify the song 
    title of that popular 80's Huey Lewis tune), this 3-piece conglomeration can 
    be quite the show stopper. Alas, since they are speakers we must eventually 
    hook them up and switch them on.
   
    
       
        | Factory 
            Specifications  | The 
            Unit  | 
       
        | 
            Total power 
              output: 40 watts RMS Frequency response: 
              30 Hz - 20 kHz Input impedance: 
              10,000 ohms Power source: 
              AC 90V-240V (auto-switching) Theatre-quality 
              sound for CD music, Internet & MP3 Headphone jack 
              Automatic on/off 
              sound detection system Integrated 
              power supply  |    Logitech
  5/10 
            Rating | 
    
   
  Description 
    & Specifications
  The SoundMan's squeeze 
    into the crowded three piece sub/sat market, which is crowded enough already. 
    Everything is round and no sharp squared off edges can be felt anywhere. Since 
    the power supply is fully internal, the picture to the right is accurate--no 
    unsightly wall warts, only a standard AC cord.
  If the satellites seem 
    small in the pic, they are even smaller in real life. While of average height, 
    they are so thin that extra care must be taken to ensure they don't fall over. 
    In some cases, you may want to consider double sided sticky tape to anchor 
    them to a surface.
  Logitech rates the output 
    to the satellites as 8 watts each and 24 watts for the sub unit for a total 
    of 40 watts amp output at 10% distortion. Apparently they think that a setup 
    like this somehow qualifies as "Theatre-quality"--emphasis on the 
    "tre" of theatre. Somehow, I can't imagine stepping behind the scenes 
    of my local cinema and being shocked as they proudly show me several sets 
    of SoundMan's projecting sound to a 500 seat auditorium. Logitech's media 
    department should review theater specs from Dolby Labs and Sony before making 
    such outrageous claims. Harrumph!
  These have the rare headphone 
    jack located at the bottom rear of the sub. However, that feature was added 
    and another removed: there is no power button. Yup, us consumers are so dumb 
    as not to know how to turn anything on anymore. Instead, the engineers that 
    be have incorporated an auto-on gate-type switch that detects when sound is 
    present. After some minutes of total silence, the small green LED atop the 
    right satellites glows amber to indicate standby mode. I'd lay money that 
    this feature saves about one cent and hour...
  Objective Measurements
  Data acquired and reported 
    of this type is done without any opinion or bias whatsoever. For a quickie 
    brush up course on audio terminology and measurements, point your browser 
    to the Audio 
    Reproduction Systems article.
  The Woofer
  Normally, I begin with 
    R.M.S. power measurements, but due to the impedance shock (look below), I 
    chose to deal with "Z" first. The impedance is extremely important 
    because it directly affects any power amp calculations.
  Logitech gives no clue 
    as to what's inside their cool looking rounded sub box. Partial disassembly 
    revealed a small-ish 4" driver instead of the more typical 6-6.5" 
    sizes found in sets in the same price range. Plainly labeled as 4 Ohm, 25W 
    the shielded driver is mounted seemingly backwards and at the top of the enclosure. 
    This is a loaded horn woofer, whereas all the sound is directed out of the 
    port, not just a fraction of it. This raises efficiency (loudness) but can 
    peak the FR in a range that the port dimensions favor.
   